Comandanti vs Grachonok
Overview
The Comandanti and the Grachonok are both Patrol vessel classes.
The Comandanti displaces 1,520 tons — 11:1 the Grachonok's 138 tons. The Comandanti reaches 25 knots vs 23 knots for the Grachonok. The Comandanti carries a crew of 70 vs 8 for the Grachonok.
The Comandanti was produced in 4 units vs 28 for the Grachonok. The Comandanti was commissioned in 2004, 5 years before the Grachonok (2009).
| Italian patrol vessel, introduced in 2004 with a 1,520-ton displacement, uses a CODAD propulsion scheme. | |
| Origin | 🇮🇹 Italy |
| Category | Patrol vessel |
| Type | Patrol vessel |
| Manufacturer | Fincantieri |
| Year introduced | 2004 |
| Number built | 4 units |
| Estimated unit price | $90.5 million |
| Commissioned by Russia from 2009, the Grachonok class is an anti-saboteur patrol boat designed for harbour defence, fitted with the Anapa-M towed diver-detection sonar. | |
| Origin | 🇷🇺 Russia |
| Category | Patrol vessel |
| Type | Anti-saboteur boat |
| Manufacturer | Zelenodolsk Shipyard |
| Year introduced | 2009 |
| Number built | 28 units |
| Estimated unit price | NA |
| Displacement | 1,520 tons ◉ |
| Maximum speed | 25.0 knots ◉ |
| Range | 3,500 nm at 14 knots |
| Length | 88.6 m ◉ |
| Beam | 12.2 m ◉ |
| Crew | 70 ◉ |
| Propulsion | CODAD scheme - 2 shaft and 2 propellers with variable-pitch; 2 x diesel engines Wärtsilä-NSD W18-V-26 XN (6,480 kW (8,690 hp) each) |
| Armament |
|
| Displacement | 138 tons ◉ |
| Maximum speed | 23.0 knots ◉ |
| Range | NA |
| Length | 31.0 m ◉ |
| Beam | 7.4 m ◉ |
| Crew | 8 ◉ |
| Propulsion | 2 × MTU / MWM-Deutz TBD620V12 or Zvezda ZE / Kolomna diesel engines |
| Armament |
|
Performance Radar Chart
Detailed Comparison
Loading analysis...
Generating comparison analysis...
Unable to generate comparison at this time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has greater displacement, the Comandanti-class or Grachonok-class?
The Comandanti-class has greater displacement at 1,520 tons compared to the Grachonok-class's 138 tons.
Which is faster, the Comandanti-class or Grachonok-class?
The Comandanti-class is faster with a maximum speed of 25 knots compared to the Grachonok-class's 23 knots.
Which has longer range, the Comandanti-class or Grachonok-class?
The Comandanti-class has a longer range at 3,500 nautical miles compared to the Grachonok-class's 0 nautical miles.
Which is longer, the Comandanti-class or Grachonok-class?
The Comandanti-class is longer at 88.6 meters compared to the Grachonok-class's 31.0 meters.
How many crew members do the Comandanti-class and Grachonok-class have?
The Comandanti-class has a larger crew complement of 70 compared to the Grachonok-class's 8 crew members.
Which has been built in greater numbers, the Comandanti-class or Grachonok-class?
The Grachonok-class has been built in greater numbers with 28 vessels compared to 4 vessels of the Comandanti-class.